Choosing a partner

Choosing a Shopify migration agency: questions, red flags and costs

Moving the products is the easy part of a Shopify migration. The hard part is everything around them: every URL changes, years of product data has to survive the trip, stock has to stay in sync, and the rankings you’ve built have to be there on launch day. This is how to choose a Shopify migration agency that protects all of it.

15 min readUpdated October 2026350+ Shopify stores500K+ products migrated20+ years
Shopify PartnersGoogle PartnerMeta Business PartnerKlaviyo K:Partners

The short answer

A good Shopify migration agency treats the move as a protection job first and a design job second. Your products, customers, order history, content and rankings all have to arrive intact, and your store has to keep trading while that happens. A new design is the reward for getting that right, not a substitute for it.

That’s the standard to hold every agency, studio and freelancer on your shortlist to. The questions and red flags below will separate them quickly.

A word on where I sit. I’m a senior-led Shopify practice rather than a large agency: I’ve engineered more than 350 Shopify stores and migrated over 500,000 products in more than 20 years in ecommerce. This guide is written to be useful whoever you choose, including if it isn’t me.

350+Shopify stores engineered
500K+Products migrated over 20 years
EveryOld URL mapped before launch
30 daysPost-launch fixes in my package

Want a second opinion on a migration quote? I’ll give you one for free.

Book a free audit

What a Shopify migration agency actually does

“Migration” covers a lot of separate jobs. A complete Shopify migration includes all of these:

  • Data audit. What you have, where it lives and how clean it is, before anything moves.
  • Catalogue migration. Products, variants, attributes, images, brands and categories, restructured for Shopify rather than copied as they were.
  • Customer and order migration. Accounts, addresses, marketing consent and order history, so repeat customers recognise the store.
  • Content migration. Pages, guides and blog posts that carry rankings of their own.
  • URL mapping and redirects. Every old address matched to its new one and permanently redirected.
  • Theme design and build. The new store itself, built around how your customers shop.
  • Integrations. Payments, EPOS, stock, ERP, accounting and finance connections rebuilt or replaced.
  • Tracking. Analytics, conversion events and ad platform pixels rebuilt and checked against real orders.
  • Launch and monitoring. A controlled switch-over, then rankings, traffic and revenue watched against a baseline.

A quote that only mentions the first two or three is a quote for a data transfer, not a migration.

Five kinds of Shopify migration company

Search for a Shopify migration company and you’ll find very different businesses offering what sounds like the same thing.

TypeWhat you getWatch for
Large agencyA full team: account manager, designers, developers, project managerWho actually does the work, and whether your project is big enough to get their senior people
Small studioA tight team that often designs and builds wellWhether they’ve handled data and redirects at your scale before
FreelancerOne person, often good value for a defined jobWho covers design, data, integrations or tracking if those aren’t their speciality
Migration tool serviceA data transfer run by the makers of a migration appData moves as it is: design, restructuring and launch are on you
Senior-led practiceOne experienced person accountable end to end, with specialists as neededCapacity: how many migrations they run at once

None of these is right for everyone. The point is to know which one you’re talking to, so you can ask the right questions.

What moves to Shopify, and what doesn’t

Knowing this up front avoids surprises in launch week, and it’s a quick test of whether an agency knows Shopify well.

DataMoves to Shopify?What to watch
Products and variantsYesUp to 3 options and 2,048 variants per product; some themes and apps handle fewer
Attributes and specificationsYes, as structured fieldsFree-text specs need cleaning before they can power filters
ImagesYesA chance to fix inconsistent sizes and missing alt text
Customers and addressesYesMarketing consent should move with each record
Customer passwordsNoCustomers sign in with a one-time email code on Shopify’s customer accounts
Order historyYes, via import toolsImported after products and customers, as historical records
ReviewsUsuallyDepends on the old and new review apps
URLsNo, they changeShopify uses fixed folders such as /products/ and /collections/
Blog and content pagesYesFormatting and internal links need checking
Based on Shopify Help Center documentation, accessed 24 October 2026. The exact picture depends on the platform you’re leaving.

The URL row matters most. Because Shopify puts every product under /products/ and every category under /collections/, and those folder names can’t be changed, almost every address on your old site changes. Each one needs a redirect, or the rankings attached to it are lost.

Where migrations go wrong

Migrating a store with 200 simple products and migrating an established retailer with 20,000 are different jobs. Bigger, older stores hit problems small ones never see.

The catalogue is data, not a list

An established catalogue carries sizes, colours, materials, finishes, specifications, bundles and brand ranges. On older platforms that often lives in inconsistent or free-text fields. Moved as it is, it can’t power filters. Restructured during the migration, it becomes the thing that makes the new store work. In specialist categories such as hi-fi, where buyers compare power ratings and connections, this can decide the whole project.

Stock lives somewhere else

Retailers with shops or warehouses run EPOS, stock or ERP systems. If the integration isn’t planned as part of the migration, online stock drifts from the shelf, and some connectors silently overwrite product data every time they sync. That can undo the migration’s work overnight.

Rankings are spread across thousands of pages

Established stores rank for individual products, model numbers and categories. Every one of those URLs changes. Miss a few hundred redirects and a slice of organic revenue disappears quietly over the following weeks.

The old platform doesn’t want to let go

Proprietary and legacy platforms often hold data in unusual structures, with limited exports. Getting it out intact is sometimes the longest part of the project, and it’s the part a generalist is least prepared for.

Twelve questions to ask a Shopify migration agency

Put these to every agency on your shortlist. Good answers are specific; vague ones tell you something too.

  1. Have you migrated a store like mine?Same platform, similar catalogue size, similar integrations. Ask to see it live.
  2. How will you map and redirect my old URLs?You want a full map before launch, not redirects added after rankings drop.
  3. What happens to my product data structure?A good answer involves restructuring, not just copying.
  4. How will you handle my EPOS, stock and ERP?Get every integration named and scoped in the quote.
  5. Will there be any downtime?The answer should be no: build in the background, switch at launch.
  6. How will customers log in after the move?They should know passwords don’t transfer and have a plan for telling customers.
  7. What baseline will you measure against?Rankings, traffic and revenue captured before work starts.
  8. Who rebuilds and checks tracking?Conversions should be verified against real orders before launch.
  9. Who will actually do the work?Names, not job titles, and whether any of it is outsourced.
  10. What’s fixed in writing?Scope, fee, payment plan and launch date, before you commit.
  11. Who owns the theme and data afterwards?It should be you, with no lock-in.
  12. What happens after launch?A defined period of monitoring and fixes, included in the price.

Red flags

“Redirects can be sorted after launch.” By then the damage has started. Redirects belong in the plan, not the snag list.

A price with no data audit behind it. Nobody can quote a migration accurately without seeing what’s being moved.

An app-only approach for a large catalogue. Import apps are useful tools, but they move data as it is.

No mention of your EPOS or stock system. For any retailer with a shop or warehouse, that’s one of the biggest variables in the project.

Tracking left to you. If no one verifies conversions before launch, you’ll be making ad decisions on broken data.

A push towards Shopify Plus before scoping. Plus is right for some stores, but the plan should follow the scope, not lead it.

Vague ownership terms. If the contract doesn’t say you own the theme and data, ask why.

On the Plus question specifically, my Shopify Plus migration guide sets out what Plus adds and when it’s worth it.

Agency, freelancer or do it yourself?

Migration app, yourself

Low

Tools such as Cart2Cart and LitExtension charge by the amount of data moved, from $29 and $59 respectively; Matrixify is a monthly app plan. Data moves as it was; design, redirects and tracking are on you.

Right for: small, simple catalogues on a clean platform.

Freelancer

Varies widely

Can work well for a defined piece of the job. Check who covers the parts outside their speciality.

Right for: stores with few integrations and a clear brief.

Recommended

Managed migration

From $24,997

Data audit, restructuring, redirects, theme, integrations and tracking handled as one project, with fixed scope and fee.

Right for: established retailers whose revenue depends on the move.

App prices are the publishers’ own published starting prices as of October 2026. For an established retailer, a managed migration usually costs less overall, because the expensive mistakes in a migration are the ones that surface after launch. If you’re weighing the options more broadly, my guide to Shopify agency vs freelancer compares them in more depth.

Notes by platform

Every platform you might be leaving has its own quirks. These are the ones that most often shape an agency’s scope.

Magento and Adobe Commerce

Large, heavily attributed catalogues with configurable products and customer groups. The data is usually well organised; the work is in restructuring it. See my Magento to Shopify migration guide.

WooCommerce

Stores often rely on a stack of plugins for filtering, bundles and product options, and the data those plugins hold doesn’t always export cleanly. WooCommerce’s built-in exporter covers products; full order and customer exports usually need an extension or a migration tool.

BigCommerce

Exports are generally clean. The main work is URL mapping, because BigCommerce URL patterns differ from Shopify’s, and rebuilding custom templates and checkout features.

Lightspeed and other POS-led platforms

The big decision is whether to keep the POS and connect it to Shopify, or move tills to Shopify too. My Lightspeed to Shopify guide walks through it.

UK hosted and proprietary platforms

Platforms such as EKM, ShopWired and Sellerdeck, and proprietary systems run by an agency, each have their own export routes and URL formats. Some export products, customers and orders to CSV; others need more work to get everything out. Check your contract’s notice period early, so the switch-over lands on your end date.

What to get in writing

Before you sign with any Shopify migration agency, make sure the agreement covers:

  • Scope: exactly which data, pages, integrations and features are included, and which aren’t.
  • Fee and payment plan: a fixed fee, what triggers each payment, and what happens if scope changes.
  • Launch date: and what each side has to deliver for it to hold.
  • Ownership: that you own the theme, the content and the data outright.
  • Post-launch support: how long, what’s covered, and how quickly issues are handled.
  • Access: that your Shopify store is in your name, with the agency added as a collaborator or staff account.

The single biggest cause of delay usually isn’t technical. It’s slow decisions on design and content. Agree who signs off, and how quickly, at the start.

What to prepare before you talk to an agency

You’ll get a faster, more accurate quote, and a better migration, if you gather a few things first:

  • Your platform and version, plus any custom modules, plugins or extensions the store relies on.
  • A rough product count, including variants, and where your product data lives today: the platform, a spreadsheet, an ERP or a supplier feed.
  • Your EPOS, stock and ERP systems, and how they talk to the website now.
  • Access to Google Search Console and analytics, so rankings and traffic can be baselined before anything changes.
  • A list of integrations: accounting, email, reviews, finance, shipping and anything else that touches orders.
  • Your contract end date with your current platform or hosting provider.
  • Your busiest trading periods, so launch avoids them.

None of this needs to be perfect. It lets the agency see the real shape of the job rather than guess at it, and it lets you compare quotes like for like.

What a good agency does in launch week

The switch-over should be the quietest part of the project. When it isn’t, it’s usually because one of these was left to the last minute:

  • A final data sync, so orders and customers added during the build come across on launch day.
  • Redirects tested in bulk, with the most valuable product and category URLs checked one by one.
  • Checkout tested end to end, with real orders placed and refunded, including finance options, discounts, tax and shipping rules.
  • DNS changed carefully, touching only the records the website needs, so email keeps working.
  • The customer email ready, explaining the new store and how to sign in.
  • Ad campaigns checked, so they point at live URLs and conversions fire on the new checkout.
  • The new sitemap submitted in Search Console, and crawl errors watched daily.

Google’s own site-move guidance warns that rankings can fluctuate while it recrawls a moved site. Small dips are normal; anything sustained should be investigated the same day.

What a Shopify migration agency costs

Prices vary widely, because “migration” covers anything from a data transfer to a full rebuild. What drives the price is the size and condition of your data, the number of integrations, the amount of design work and how much custom functionality has to be rebuilt.

My Shopify migration package starts from $24,997 USD, or £18,747 + VAT for UK clients, with flexible plans depending on the deposit paid. It covers the audit and data map, a custom theme, migration of products, images, customers, orders and content, every old address redirected, integrations connected, launch, and 30 days of post-launch fixes. It runs over four weeks from signed brief to a live store. I’m UK-based and work remotely with retailers all over the world. Outside the UK, the package starts from $24,997 with no VAT, quoted in US dollars after the free store audit.

My Shopify migration cost guide breaks down what moves the price, whoever you choose.

Shopify migration agency guide: a group of people around a white table in a planning meeting
The best migrations are the ones customers don’t notice, except that the store got better.

How I run a migration

  1. Week 1: audit and mapProducts, customers, orders, URLs, integrations and rankings reviewed. Every old URL mapped. Design direction and launch date agreed.
  2. Week 2: design and buildA custom theme built to your brand while your current store keeps trading.
  3. Week 3: move and connectData imported, payments, shipping and stock systems connected and tested, redirects loaded.
  4. Week 4: test and launchCheckout tested on real devices, a final data sync so no orders are lost, then go-live with 30 days of support.

Very large catalogues or complex integrations can take longer, and I’ll tell you if yours will after the audit, before you commit. Lipton’s Audio & Video’s move, with more than 2,800 products migrated, is set out in the Lipton’s Shopify migration case study.

When you don’t need an agency

  • Your store is small and simple. A few dozen or a few hundred products, no integrations and little search traffic: a migration app and a good theme may be enough.
  • You’re moving from a platform Shopify supports directly. Shopify’s free Store Migration app imports products and customers from platforms including WooCommerce, Wix, Etsy and Square. It doesn’t handle orders, redirects or content, so it suits smaller stores best.
  • You have a capable in-house team. If you have developers who know Shopify, you may only need help with the parts they don’t cover, such as redirects or data restructuring.

If your store is established and the revenue matters, the cost of a managed move is usually small next to the cost of getting it wrong. For the full service, see my Shopify migration service.

Find out what your migration involves before you choose anyone.

Book a free audit

Shopify migration agency: FAQ

It moves your store to Shopify: data audit, product, customer and order migration, content, URL mapping and redirects, theme design and build, integrations, tracking, and a monitored launch.
Ask whether they’ve moved a store like yours, how they handle redirects and data structure, how they’ll connect your stock and EPOS systems, what’s fixed in writing, who owns the work afterwards, and what support follows launch.
It varies with data size, integrations and design work. My Shopify migration package starts from $24,997 USD, or £18,747 + VAT for UK clients, with flexible plans depending on the deposit paid.
Not really. Both terms cover businesses that move stores to Shopify, from large agencies to freelancers and migration-tool services. What matters is what’s included and who does the work.
A migration app suits a small, simple store. For an established retailer, an agency or specialist handles the restructuring, redirects, design, integrations and tracking that apps don’t.
Not if the migration is managed properly. Every old URL is mapped and permanently redirected before launch, metadata moves with the content, and rankings are monitored against a baseline.
No. Passwords can’t move between platforms. Customer accounts and order history are imported, and customers sign in with a one-time code sent to their email.
My Shopify migration package runs over four weeks from signed brief to a live store. Very large catalogues or complex integrations can take longer, which I’ll tell you after the audit.
It shouldn’t. The new store is built in the background while the old one keeps trading, and the switch happens on launch day after a final data sync.
You should. Make sure the contract gives you the theme, content and data outright, and that the Shopify store is in your name.
Only if you need Shopify Plus. Many established retailers don’t, especially since core B2B features reached the lower plans in April 2026.
Your platform and version, a rough product and variant count, a list of integrations, access to Search Console and analytics, your busiest trading periods and who signs off decisions.

Sources

Shopify product, variant, redirect and URL rules: Shopify Help Center, accessed 24 October 2026; variant limit from the Shopify changelog, 15 October 2025. Customer passwords and customer accounts: Shopify Help Center, accessed 24 October 2026. Store Migration app: Shopify blog, 21 July 2026. B2B on non-Plus plans: Shopify changelog, 2 April 2026. WooCommerce exports: WooCommerce documentation, accessed 24 October 2026. Migration app prices: Cart2Cart (minimum fee $29), LitExtension (from $59) and Matrixify (Shopify App Store listing), accessed 24 October 2026. KA Consultancy prices, proof points and process as published on the Shopify migration services page; migration results from the Lipton’s Audio & Video case study.

Free store audit

Get a straight answer on your migration.

A free review of your store, catalogue, integrations and rankings, with the risks named and a fixed price for the move, whether or not you choose me.